The fan in me wanted to say so many things after Sunday's OT loss. He wanted to rip Mike Sherman for the play-calling late in the fourth quarter. He wanted Legedu Naanee cut first thing Monday morning. He wanted Dan Carpenter left behind in Arizona to take lessons from former Fins kicker, and Sunday's game-winning kicker, Jay Feely.
But I knew those were knee-jerk reactions from a fan. Fair reactions? Possibly. But knee-jerk nonetheless. So the journalist in me thought better of it, and decided to give it a day or two before truly giving an evaluation. And in doing so, I've realized a few things from re-watching film, listening to press conferences, and looking at the first quarter of this season as a whole.
Number one is, Ryan Tannehill is going to be a good, and has the potential to be a great, quarterback in this league for a long time. No, don't call me a homer, because I would hope you know by now that I call it like I see it. I've sat through the Fiedler-Beck-Lemon-Henne-Moore era's, and I can tell you right now, with absolutely no doubt in my mind, that this, folks, is different. The stats, as coach Joe Philbin said yesterday, are a bit deceiving. Yes, Tannehill only has two touchdowns next to six interceptions. Yes, the kid's completing just over half of his passes through the first four games. But the intangibles that Tannehill brings to the table week after week are something I haven't seen out of a Dolphins QB not named Chad Pennington in all my life.
The poise in the pocket, for starters, is really quite remarkable considering that this is Tannehill's what, 24th career start at QB this Sunday? This from ESPN's stats inc..:
“Ryan Tannehill faced extra pressure on 25 of his 44 dropbacks, and completed 16-of-22 passes for 306 yards, a touchdown and an interception against at least five pass rushers. Tannehill’s 306 passing yards against at least five pass rushers is the highest single-game total by anyone since the start of the 2008 season.”
“More impressive for Tannehill is who it came against–entering Sunday, the Cardinals’ defense led the league with a 34.1 completion percentage and 3.6 yards per attempt allowed when sending at least five pass rushers."
To me, this was most evident in the 3rd quarter of Sunday's game, when Tannehill dropped back to pass on third down and three from his own 43 yard line. Jonathan Martin was beat off the edge and Tannehill had a drive ending sack headed his way. However, where the like's of, say, Chad Henne would have taken a sure sack, Tannehill stepped up in the pocket, evaded the blitz, and threw a 30 yard touch pass to the well defended Brian Hartline at the Cardinals 27 yard line for a first down.
Rookie QB's just don't do that, folks. This one does.
Here's something else that sets the rookie apart from the previous failures before him. Tannehill’s 94.8 rating in the fourth quarter this season is 11th-best in the league, and leads all rookie QB's in his class. I don't have the exact stat on them, but I can guarantee you that Chad Henne and John Beck came no where near that number.
And all this is coming during a stretch where Tannehill faced two of the leagues unbeaten teams on the road, and if you include the Jets, three of the NFL's more blitz-heavy defenses.
The second thing I realized is, first year coach Joe Philbin is no Tony Sparano, or Cam Cameron, or Nick Saban, or Dave Wannstedt.
And this is a wonderful, wonderful sight.
His demeanor, on and off the field, is something I've never seen before in all my years following this team. He hold's his player accountable, for starters, but at the same time instills a quiet confidence in them. Take Sean Smith for example, who had two huge interceptions on Sunday, yet was responsible for the game tying touchdown catch on fourth down.
Here's what Philbin said.
When asked about the play of Sean Smith:
“I thought he did a lot of good things. I thought there was a couple impact plays that he made and really they’re quality plays when you watch them on film. You like them. I thought he did a good job.”
When asked about the game tying touchdown:
"Obviously, Sean Smith's over there...we’ve got to have tighter coverage in the flesh.”
Confidence, yet accountability. Joe Philbin has done this since day one, and it's something we haven't seen out of a Miami coach in a long time.
The second thing I noticed when watching the rookie head coach is the comfort I feel with him at the helm. Tony Sparano, God bless him for trying, never really struck me as a head coach. He was a great motivational speaker, and he had a great football mind, but, and I think most fans will agree with me here, you just never felt comfortable with him. Not in game situations, not in game planning, and certainly not with quarterback development.
This, I believe, is where Joe Philbin excels. Listening to the way he speaks of this football team, watching him on the sidelines, and most importantly, watching the product of football on the field (yes, I did just coin that term from Philbin himself) shows me that the decision Steve Ross and Jeff Ireland made back in January was absolutely spot on. Philbin knows he has a young team, with a young QB, but at the same time, knows the potential of this team, and you can see it with every little smirk he gives in a press conference, or on the sidelines.
I trust him with Ryan Tannehill. I trust him with the offensive game planning. And, above all, I trust him with the direction of this football team. That's something I haven't been able to say, well, ever.
I can say it now with full confidence.
You may be reading this and calling me a dreamer, or a homer, or just a plain bad journalist. Thats completely fine, folks, I understand where you're coming from, the fan inside of me knows all too well.
But this team is different. If you've watched for as long as I have then I think you'll agree with me. Despite a 1-3 record out of this young group I think the tide is finally turning in Miami.
Lets grab a spot on the beach and watch it roll on into Cincinnati.